Written By Jordannah Elizabeth Graham-Mayer

There is a particular kind of inconvenience that comes with being married to a songwriter. You can be sitting in a perfectly ordinary room, surrounded by perfectly ordinary domestic problems, and discover that your husband has made something beautiful out of a situation you would have preferred he simply resolve.
A song, for instance.
John has a new one. “Tom and Jerry.” His first solo single in five years, which is a long time to wait for anything, although five years in a marriage can feel like either an afternoon or a geological period depending on what is happening in the kitchen.
I listened to it, and my first thought was that it sounded like a man having an affair.
Not that I have discovered an affair. There is a difference between hearing a song that sounds like an affair and discovering that your husband is having one. I would like to preserve that distinction, if only because marriage is already complicated enough without having to conduct an investigation every time a guitar sounds particularly convincing.
But the song has that quality. Somebody is elusive. Somebody is not coming through. Somebody is being pursued, or is doing the pursuing, and the whole arrangement seems to depend on the possibility that the person who wants to leave might suddenly decide to stay. There is a suggestion of secrecy, or at least of a relationship that cannot quite be brought into the daylight without losing some of its appeal.
It is romantic in the way that a locked door is romantic when you are standing on the wrong side of it.
John tells me the song is about our marriage.
I looked at him.
There are times when the appropriate response to one’s husband is not a sentence but a look. We have developed several varieties over the years, including the look that means I have heard you, the look that means I do not believe you have thought this through, and the look that means I love you but you are making my life unnecessarily difficult.
This was some combination of the three.
I do not know what he expected me to say. Thank you for the song? How flattering to be the woman in a song about running away with somebody who might never show up? Perhaps I should be pleased that our marriage has inspired a song whose central emotional problem appears to be whether the relationship will ever actually happen.
We are married. The relationship has, in a technical sense, happened.
But John has always had a way of making the technically settled feel emotionally unresolved. I suspect this is part of what makes him a songwriter. It is also part of what makes being his wife an activity that occasionally requires a great deal of patience.
The strange thing is that I believe him.
Or perhaps I believe that he believes it. There is a difference, and I have reached an age where I am no longer embarrassed to admit that the difference matters.
A person can write about longing for somebody who is already beside him. A person can be devoted to a marriage and still find something compelling about the possibility of losing it. Desire is not always interested in the practical arrangements. It does not necessarily become sensible because two people have exchanged vows, acquired responsibilities, and begun arguing about things that would bore anybody who was not involved.
The song is not an invoice. It does not have to account for every feeling.
Still, I would have preferred something with a slightly less suspicious premise.
The title began as the name John gave a voice memo. I find this detail useful because it reminds me that the song did not arrive in the world as a carefully prepared statement about his wife. It began as an idea he wanted to remember. Somewhere between the voice memo and the finished recording, the idea became a song, and the song became something people could listen to and interpret however they pleased.
Nonetheless, this is the trouble with being married to somebody whose work is public. The rest of us get to have thoughts without anybody asking whether those thoughts are autobiographical. A songwriter puts a feeling into a recording, and suddenly the feeling belongs to everybody who hears it.
Somebody hears an affair. Somebody hears a breakup. Somebody hears the great love of their life, who left in 2019 and still has not returned the sweater.
I hear my husband.
Continue reading
